A Landscape Scan of Practices Across Prosecutors’ Offices
Setting the Standard
Public Safety, Justice, and Accountability in Prosecution
Prosecutors are entrusted with significant authority and a fundamental responsibility to seek justice. Their decisions shape public safety, individual rights, and the integrity of the justice system.
Setting the Standard examines policies and practices across nearly 30 prosecutors’ offices. It documents how prosecutors are responding ethically and effectively to crime, exercising independent judgment, serving victims, protecting constitutional rights, and strengthening the administration of justice.
The Responsibility to Seek Justice
Prosecutors make consequential decisions throughout the justice process, from determining which charges to pursue and how cases should be resolved to protecting victims, upholding constitutional rights, and reviewing past convictions.
For too long, prosecutorial success has been measured too narrowly, with convictions and sentence lengths receiving more attention than the full impact of those decisions. The responsibility to seek justice requires a broader view of what prosecutors must do and how their decisions affect the people and communities they serve.
That responsibility calls for independent judgment grounded in the facts, the law, public safety, victims’ needs and interests, proportionality, and constitutional and ethical obligations. It also means examining outcomes, addressing misconduct and past injustices, and changing practices when evidence shows a need for improvement.
Setting the Standard brings together approaches from prosecutors’ offices across the country, offering practical examples of how they are carrying out the full scope of those responsibilities.
What the report examines
Four Themes of Responsible Prosecution
Prosecutorial authority is exercised locally, and communities have distinct needs, priorities, and public safety challenges. Offices also operate under different laws and with varying resources. Across those differences, the report identifies four overarching themes.
Respond Effectively to Crime and Protect Public Safety
Prosecutors have a responsibility to respond effectively to criminal conduct, hold people accountable, and seek justice while working to prevent future harm.
The report highlights targeted enforcement, investigative partnerships, and evidence-informed prevention strategies. It also examines how prosecutors can coordinate with law enforcement while retaining the independent judgment needed to evaluate evidence, protect rights, and address misconduct.
Practices highlighted: Gun violence prevention, responses to serious crime, law enforcement coordination and oversight, public health partnerships, and pre-arrest deflection.
Use Prosecutorial Discretion with Integrity
Responsible prosecutorial discretion calls for independent, individualized, and proportionate decisions informed by the evidence, the law, public safety, victims’ interests, and the circumstances of each case.
Offices are applying that judgment throughout the justice process, including charging, pretrial decisions, plea negotiations, diversion, and post-conviction review.
Practices highlighted: Individualized charging and pretrial decisions, diversion, restorative justice, ethical plea bargaining, developmentally appropriate responses to youth, and conviction and sentencing review.
Serve Victims, Engage the Community, and Uphold Rights
Serving victims and witnesses, upholding constitutional rights, and understanding community concerns are fundamental responsibilities of prosecution.
The report highlights trauma-informed victim support, responses to economic exploitation, and opportunities for community input. These efforts can inform office practices without compromising prosecutors’ obligation to make decisions based on the facts, the law, and the duty to seek justice.
Practices highlighted: Trauma-informed victim services, responses to economic exploitation, community engagement, and record clearance.
Build a Transparent and Effective Prosecutor’s Office
The responsible exercise of prosecutorial authority depends on the safeguards, internal systems, and workplace practices that support ethical and consistent decisions.
The report examines offices using data and independent evaluation to assess outcomes, identify disparities, strengthen constitutional and discovery compliance, and improve decision-making. It also highlights staff support and professional development.
Practices highlighted: Data transparency, performance evaluation, independent research, constitutional compliance, internal safeguards, and staff well-being.
“For too long, our profession has defined success too narrowly, focusing on convictions and lengthy sentences without fully examining the consequences of our decisions. That narrow view has meant overlooking the full weight of our responsibility to protect public safety, serve victims, uphold constitutional rights, and seek justice. The practices highlighted in this report reflect prosecutors taking ownership of those responsibilities, examining outcomes, confronting shortcomings, and changing course when the evidence demands it.”
Aramis N. Donell
Executive Director, Fair and Just Prosecution
About the Research
Setting the Standard draws on interviews with prosecutors leading 26 offices and a review of policies and practices across 29 prosecutors’ offices representing diverse geographic regions and communities.
The research was conducted in late 2025 and early 2026. For three offices, the analysis relied primarily on publicly available policies, records, and other materials.
The report is a landscape scan, not a nationally representative survey, a ranking of prosecutors’ offices, or an independent evaluation of every practice documented. It brings together examples and available evidence to inform discussions about prosecutorial responsibility, effectiveness, and the fair administration of justice.
Why This Report Matters
The role of prosecutors is the subject of intense public debate, yet the full scope of their responsibilities can be overlooked in discussions of individual policies or cases.
Through examples from different jurisdictions, Setting the Standard offers a closer look at what effective prosecution means in practice: how offices are responding to public safety challenges, examining outcomes, confronting shortcomings, and applying independent judgment in the communities they serve.
The report provides a resource for prosecutors, policymakers, researchers, journalists, legal practitioners, and community organizations. We also hope this report will help communities raise their expectations of what prosecution should deliver: not simply convictions, but the fair, ethical, and accountable exercise of power that protects rights, strengthens public safety, and advances justice.
Learn more
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Setting the Standard?
Setting the Standard: Public Safety, Justice, and Accountability in Prosecution is a national landscape scan examining how prosecutors across the country are exercising their authority to protect public safety, uphold constitutional rights, serve victims, and pursue justice. The report documents policies and practices across 29 prosecutors’ offices and highlights examples of how those responsibilities are being carried out in different jurisdictions.
Why did Fair and Just Prosecution produce this report?
For too long, success in prosecution has been measured too narrowly, with convictions and sentence lengths receiving more attention than the full impact of prosecutorial decisions. This limited view has often overlooked the broader responsibilities prosecutors have to protect public safety, serve victims, uphold constitutional rights, and hold themselves accountable. Across the country, prosecutors are developing and implementing practices that reflect a fuller understanding of their responsibilities. FJP developed Setting the Standard to document that work, identify common themes, and share examples that can inform how prosecutors respond to public safety challenges, strengthen decision-making, and improve the administration of justice.
How was the report developed?
The landscape scan draws on interviews with prosecutors leading 26 offices and a review of policies and practices across 29 offices representing diverse geographic regions and communities. The research was conducted in late 2025 and early 2026. It is a landscape scan rather than a nationally representative survey or a comprehensive evaluation of every practice documented.
What are the report’s key themes?
The report identifies four overarching themes:
- Responding Effectively to Crime and Protecting Public Safety: Responding to criminal conduct, strengthening coordination and accountability with law enforcement, and using evidence-informed strategies to prevent violence and future harm.
- Using Prosecutorial Discretion with Integrity: Making independent, individualized, and proportionate decisions throughout the justice process, from charging and pretrial decisions to plea bargaining, diversion, and post-conviction review.
- Serving Victims, Engaging the Community, and Upholding Rights: Supporting victims and witnesses, addressing economic exploitation, incorporating community perspectives, and protecting individual rights throughout the justice process.
- Building a Transparent and Effective Prosecutor’s Office: Using data, independent evaluation, internal safeguards, and staff support to strengthen decision-making, promote fairness and consistency, and ensure meaningful scrutiny of prosecutorial practices.
Does the report recommend a single approach to prosecution?
No. Prosecutorial authority is exercised locally, and prosecutors are responsible for making decisions within the jurisdictions they serve. Each community also has its own needs, priorities, and public safety challenges. Prosecutors operate under different laws and with varying resources. Rather than prescribing a single model, the report illustrates how prosecutors are applying their legal and ethical responsibilities in different contexts, using sound judgment, integrity, and a commitment to public safety and justice.
How does the report address accountability for serious crimes?
The report recognizes that prosecutors have a fundamental responsibility to respond effectively to criminal conduct, protect public safety, hold people accountable, and seek justice. That includes pursuing serious charges and appropriate sentences when warranted by the facts and law. It also requires prosecutors to consider the circumstances of each case, the strength of the evidence, victims’ needs and interests, and potential risks to public safety. The report highlights approaches ranging from targeted enforcement and specialized investigations to prevention and diversion, recognizing that the appropriate response depends on the facts and circumstances.
What does prosecutorial independence mean, and how does it relate to accountability?
Prosecutorial independence is essential to ensuring that decisions are made based on the facts, the law, constitutional obligations, and the duty to seek justice, rather than political pressure or other improper influences. But independence does not place prosecutors beyond scrutiny. The report emphasizes that prosecutors must also be transparent about how they exercise their authority, maintain safeguards against misconduct and error, evaluate their decisions and outcomes, and remain accountable to the communities they serve.
What role do victims play in the approaches highlighted in the report?
Serving victims is a core responsibility of prosecution. The report highlights approaches that seek to ensure victims are treated with dignity, receive meaningful information and support, and have opportunities to communicate their needs and concerns throughout the justice process. These include trauma-informed services, improved communication, and restorative justice processes, when appropriate. Prosecutors must consider victims’ interests alongside the facts, applicable law, constitutional obligations, and public safety when determining an appropriate response.
What types of practices does the report highlight?
The report examines approaches to gun violence prevention, law enforcement coordination and oversight, diversion, restorative justice, conviction and sentencing review, trauma-informed victim services, community engagement, and data transparency. It also highlights how offices are strengthening internal decision-making, constitutional compliance, and performance evaluation.
Does the report evaluate whether these practices are effective?
The report includes available research, evaluations, and outcomes reported by participating offices. However, it is not an independent evaluation of every program or a study establishing that particular practices will produce the same results across jurisdictions. It emphasizes the importance of using evidence to assess outcomes and adjust practices when necessary. Readers interested in learning more about specific programs, including their implementation, evaluations, and results, are encouraged to contact the respective prosecutors’ offices for additional information.
Does featuring an office or program mean FJP endorses every aspect of its approach?
No. The report highlights specific policies and practices to illustrate how prosecutors in different jurisdictions are approaching common responsibilities and challenges. Inclusion of an office or program does not constitute an endorsement of every policy or decision made by that office. The report is intended to document practices, identify lessons, and encourage continued evaluation and improvement, recognizing that approaches must be assessed within their particular legal and community contexts.
Who can benefit from this report?
The report is intended primarily for prosecutors and their offices, but it may also be useful to policymakers, researchers, journalists, legal practitioners, and community organizations. Its examples offer opportunities to learn from different jurisdictions and improve public safety, fairness, and the responsible exercise of their authority. We also hope this report will help communities raise their expectations of what prosecution should deliver: not simply convictions, but the fair, ethical, and accountable exercise of power that protects rights, strengthens public safety, and advances justice.